Supreme Court of India Reviews Brain Death Certification Protocols Amid Concerns
SC seeks AIIMS review of brain death norms; experts say existing protocol adequate
The Times Of IndiaImage: The Times Of India
The Supreme Court of India is reviewing brain death certification protocols following a petition alleging malpractice in declaring brain death for organ donation. Experts argue that existing protocols are sufficient, while the court seeks input from a committee at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) on the necessity of additional tests like EEG and angiogram.
- 01The Supreme Court is examining brain death certification processes in India.
- 02Concerns were raised about the reliability of the apnea test used to confirm brain death.
- 03Experts believe existing protocols are adequate and additional tests may not be necessary.
- 04India sees only about 1,100 deceased organ donations annually despite a large potential donor pool.
- 05A study indicates a lack of formal training among doctors in brain death certification.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
The Supreme Court of India is investigating the protocols for certifying brain death, responding to a petition that claims some patients are incorrectly declared brain dead to facilitate organ donations. The court has requested an expert committee from the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) to assess whether additional tests, such as electroencephalograms (EEG) and angiograms, are needed. However, experts argue that the current protocols, governed by the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act of 1994, are sufficient. Dr. Manjari Tripathi, head of neurology at AIIMS, noted that the process requires certification by a panel of four independent doctors and must be confirmed twice with a minimum gap of six hours. The apnea test, which is the standard method for confirming brain death, is considered reliable globally, although it has been criticized for its subjectivity. The court's inquiry comes amid a significant gap in organ donations in India, where only about 1,100 deceased donations occur annually, equating to 0.77 per million of the population. A recent study highlighted that fewer than half of doctors have formal training in brain death certification, contributing to the under-recognition of eligible cases for organ donation.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
The review could lead to improved protocols for brain death certification, potentially increasing the number of organ donations in India.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Reader Poll
Do you support the Supreme Court's review of brain death certification protocols?
Connecting to poll...
More about All India Institute of Medical Sciences

Supreme Court Orders Review of Brain Death Protocols at AIIMS
The Indian Express • May 2, 2026

Court Decisions Reflect Controversial Stance on Late-Term Abortions in India
The Indian Express • May 1, 2026

AIIMS Highlights Risks of Medical Termination of Pregnancy in Supreme Court Case
The Indian Express • May 1, 2026
Read the original article
Visit the source for the complete story.




