Waterproof mascara is popular for its long-lasting wear, but removing it can be a challenge without causing irritation to the sensitive skin around the eyes. Dermatologist Mona Gohara advises using oil-based eye makeup removers, micellar water, or cleansing balms specifically designed to dissolve waterproof products. The key is to apply these products gently, using a soaked cotton pad to pat and swipe over the lashes without excessive rubbing, which can lead to irritation and broken lashes. Oil-based removers are effective because they dissolve oil-based makeup, while micellar water, like the La Roche-Posay Toleriane Micellar Water, is a great choice for sensitive skin due to its gentle formulation. Although makeup wipes can be convenient, they are not recommended due to their environmental impact and potential for skin irritation. If used, they should be followed by a facial cleanser to ensure all makeup is removed. Overall, gentle techniques and the right products are essential for maintaining healthy skin around the eyes.