Stanford Study Finds Short-Term Phone Bans in Schools May Backfire
Stanford-led study reveals that school phone bans backfired at first
Sfgate
Image: Sfgate
A Stanford University-led study reveals that while phone bans in schools reduced in-class phone usage significantly, they initially led to increased disciplinary issues and a decline in student well-being. The study emphasizes the need for further research on the long-term effects of such policies.
- 01Phone bans reduced in-class usage from 61% to 13%.
- 02Initial year saw a 16% increase in suspensions and a decline in student well-being.
- 03Clear academic benefits from phone bans were not observed in the first year.
- 04Positive changes in student behavior and well-being emerged after two to three years.
- 05The study calls for a continuous improvement approach to phone ban policies.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
A recent study by the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research examined the impact of phone bans in schools, particularly those using Yondr pouches to lock away student phones. The research tracked 43,000 middle and high schools over three years and found that while phone usage during class dropped significantly from 61% to 13%, the initial effects were not as beneficial as anticipated. In the first year, schools reported a 16% increase in suspensions and a decline in student well-being, with no significant improvements in test scores or attendance. Researchers, including Thomas Dee from Stanford, noted that students exhibited disruptive behavior when deprived of their phones, likening it to withdrawal symptoms. However, after two to three years, students' well-being began to improve, and disciplinary issues decreased. The study highlights that while phone bans can be effective, their implementation needs careful consideration and further research to optimize their impact. California Governor Gavin Newsom has supported these efforts, signing legislation requiring schools to limit cellphone use, reflecting a nationwide trend where about two-thirds of U.S. states have enacted similar bans.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
The findings suggest that while phone bans can reduce distractions, they may initially lead to increased behavioral issues among students, impacting school environments.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Reader Poll
Do you support phone bans in schools as a way to improve student focus?
Connecting to poll...
Read the original article
Visit the source for the complete story.




