New Zealand's Rising Remand Costs Highlight Flaws in Prison Policy
It costs a million dollars a day to keep low-risk defendants on remand. More prisons aren’t the answer
The Conversation
Image: The Conversation
New Zealand's government plans to spend NZ$503 million on prisons to address a projected 36% increase in the prison population by 2035. However, over half of the remand population poses no risk, costing taxpayers nearly NZ$1 million daily. Experts argue that resources should be redirected towards early intervention and support services instead of expanding prison facilities.
- 01The remand population in New Zealand has increased from 13% in 2000 to 41% of the total prison population.
- 02Each remand detainee costs taxpayers approximately NZ$414 per day, totaling nearly NZ$1 million daily for those posing no risk.
- 03Legislative changes, particularly the 2013 amendment to the Bail Act, have made it harder for defendants to secure bail, increasing remand rates.
- 04Most violent crimes in New Zealand occur in private homes, not public spaces, challenging the narrative that more prisons enhance public safety.
- 05Investing in early intervention and support services could reduce crime and is more cost-effective than maintaining an expanding prison system.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
The New Zealand government has allocated NZ$503 million to manage a projected 36% increase in the prison population by 2035, aiming to enhance public safety. However, the current remand population, which constitutes 41% of all prisoners, costs taxpayers nearly NZ$1 million daily, with over half of these individuals likely to avoid prison sentences. This surge in remand is largely due to a 2013 amendment to the Bail Act, which shifted the burden of proof onto defendants, making it harder for them to secure bail. Experts argue that this approach is counterproductive, as it disrupts lives and fails to address the root causes of crime, particularly domestic violence, which predominantly occurs in private settings. They advocate for reallocating funds towards early intervention strategies that address underlying issues such as mental health and addiction, which are more effective and less costly than expanding prison facilities. The article emphasizes that investing in community support rather than incarceration could yield significant long-term benefits.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
The high costs of remand are straining public finances and diverting funds from potential community support initiatives.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Reader Poll
What do you think is the best approach to reduce crime rates?
Connecting to poll...
Read the original article
Visit the source for the complete story.