The AFL appeal board's recent decision to reduce Lance Collard's suspension for allegedly using a homophobic slur from nine games to four has sparked significant backlash. Critics, including former AFLW player Kate McCarthy and journalist Marnie Vinall, have expressed their disappointment, arguing that the ruling contradicts the AFL's commitment to eradicating discrimination from the sport. The appeal board's statement, which suggested that such language is commonplace in competitive football, has been labeled as dangerous and irresponsible. It implies that homophobic, racist, and sexist comments are acceptable as long as they do not offend the targeted individuals, a sentiment that many find offensive and harmful. This decision not only affects the perception of the AFL's zero-tolerance policy but also has broader implications for the queer community and others facing discrimination. Advocates for inclusivity within the AFL are dismayed, feeling that years of advocacy have been reversed by this ruling, which undermines efforts to create a safe and welcoming environment for all players and fans.