As Scott Pendlebury approaches the milestone of 433 games, Collingwood Football Club is grappling with a decline in performance that raises questions about their chances for the AFL Premiership. Historically known for their resilience, the Pies have struggled this season, ranking 15th in points scored. Injuries to pivotal players such as Pendlebury and captain Darcy Moore have compounded their challenges, leading to a stark contrast in their ability to win close matches. Previously, Collingwood excelled in tight games, winning 82% of those decided by single digits under coach Craig McRae. However, their recent record shows a troubling drop to 29% in similar situations. This shift in performance and mindset suggests that the team may no longer believe they are in contention for the title, making Pendlebury's record-breaking game a bittersweet occasion amidst their struggles.