Supreme Court Urges High Courts to Protect Subordinate Judicial Officers from Public Criticism
SC cautions HCs against growing tendency to publicly criticise subordinate judicial officers
The Economic TimesImage: The Economic Times
The Supreme Court of India has warned high courts against publicly criticizing subordinate judicial officers, emphasizing their role as guardians of the district judiciary. This caution follows a case where the Calcutta High Court unjustly canceled an accused's bail after eight years, highlighting the need for a supportive judicial environment.
- 01Supreme Court emphasizes high courts' responsibility to protect subordinate judicial officers.
- 02Recent trend of public criticism may harm judicial officers' careers and morale.
- 03High courts should use their supervisory powers to nurture rather than oppress.
- 04An in-house mechanism can address flaws in judicial orders without public disparagement.
- 05Judicial officers deserve support to maintain the integrity of the district judiciary.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
The Supreme Court of India has cautioned high courts against the increasing trend of publicly criticizing subordinate judicial officers. A bench comprising Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta made this observation while overturning a Calcutta High Court decision that canceled an accused's bail in a tenancy-related criminal case after nearly eight years. The Supreme Court noted that the dispute was primarily civil and criticized the high court for unsettling the bail order on technical grounds. The court stressed that high courts should act as guardians of district judiciary officers, as adverse remarks can damage their careers and demoralize the entire judicial system. It suggested that high courts utilize a supportive in-house mechanism to address any flaws in judicial orders, rather than resorting to public disparagement. This approach aims to foster a nurturing environment for judicial officers, in line with the supervisory powers granted by Article 227 of the Indian Constitution.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
This ruling is significant for the judicial community, as it aims to protect the integrity and morale of judicial officers, which ultimately affects the administration of justice.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Reader Poll
Should high courts adopt measures to protect the dignity of subordinate judicial officers?
Connecting to poll...
Read the original article
Visit the source for the complete story.


