The Case for Nathan Cleary: Should NSW Stick with Him in Origin?
Will ANY Blues fans say the bloody obvious about Nathan Cleary? I'll be crucified - but NSW must be ready to make a brutal call after Game 1: PVO
Image: Mail Online
Nathan Cleary, despite being a top performer in the NRL with multiple premierships, has struggled to replicate that success in State of Origin. As NSW prepares for Game 1, there are concerns about whether Cleary can rise to the occasion, prompting discussions about potentially replacing him with Mitchell Moses if the Blues falter.
- 01Nathan Cleary is regarded as the best club footballer of his generation but has not dominated State of Origin.
- 02Cleary's style is built on control and system reliance, which may not translate effectively to the faster-paced Origin environment.
- 03Mitchell Moses has proven to be a more effective Origin halfback, showcasing a sharper edge and adaptability in high-pressure situations.
- 04NSW's selection strategy often prioritizes club performance over suitability for the unique challenges of Origin.
- 05If NSW loses Game 1, there are calls for selectors to consider replacing Cleary with Moses to enhance their chances in the series.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Nathan Cleary, the Penrith Panthers' star halfback, is widely recognized as one of the best players in the NRL, having led his team to multiple premierships. However, his performance in State of Origin has not matched his club success, raising questions about his effectiveness in the representative arena. As NSW prepares for Game 1, the potential for a 'brutal selection call' looms if Cleary fails to deliver. Critics argue that while Cleary excels in club football, his game-management style has not translated well to the faster, more unforgiving Origin format. In contrast, Mitchell Moses has emerged as a strong contender for the halfback position, having demonstrated a more aggressive and adaptable approach in previous Origin matches. The article emphasizes that NSW's historical tendency to select players based on club reputation rather than their fit for the unique demands of Origin could be detrimental. If the Blues struggle in Game 1, selectors may need to reconsider their strategy and possibly make a change to maximize their chances of success in the series.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
The performance of Nathan Cleary in Game 1 could influence the selection decisions for the remainder of the State of Origin series, affecting team dynamics and fan expectations.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Reader Poll
Should NSW replace Nathan Cleary with Mitchell Moses if they lose Game 1?
Connecting to poll...
Read the original article
Visit the source for the complete story.