Birmingham Labour has come under intense scrutiny following a recent local election defeat, attributed to a leadership imposed by the party's National Executive Committee (NEC) rather than local members. Insiders have criticized the party for being run by unelected bureaucrats, resulting in a 'catastrophic outcome' that has left the party's future in the city uncertain. Former councillors have expressed their disdain for the NEC's approach, stating it has treated local members with 'contempt' and has led to a culture of 'self-harm' within the party. A critical internal report revealed serious issues, including bullying and a lack of engagement, prompting calls for a complete overhaul of the party's operations in Birmingham. Veteran councillors Phil Davis and Liz Clements have urged for a return to local democracy and for the party to listen to its members, emphasizing that the current top-down control has alienated local activists and contributed to the electoral loss. As the new leadership, led by Coun Nicky Brennan, takes charge, the party faces mounting pressure to address these internal issues and restore trust within its ranks.