Sydney Academic's AI-Written Opinion Piece Sparks Controversy Over Academic Integrity
Sydney academic used AI to write SMH opinion piece urging students to avoid using tech to ‘cut corners’
The Guardian
Image: The Guardian
Prof. Cath Ellis from Western Sydney University used AI to draft an opinion piece for the Sydney Morning Herald, urging students to avoid shortcuts in their education. The article was removed for not disclosing AI usage, raising concerns about academic integrity and editorial standards.
- 01Prof. Cath Ellis's opinion piece urged students to engage fully in their studies and not rely on AI.
- 02The Sydney Morning Herald removed the article after discovering it was AI-generated without disclosure.
- 03Ellis used a Large Language Model by uploading 40,000 words of her own work to assist in drafting the piece.
- 04The university defended the AI usage as appropriate, citing it as a sophisticated tool for summarizing her expertise.
- 05The incident highlights growing concerns over the use of AI in academic and journalistic contexts.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Prof. Cath Ellis, pro vice-chancellor for quality and integrity at Western Sydney University, wrote an opinion piece for the Sydney Morning Herald, urging students to avoid using AI to shortcut their education. However, the piece was later removed after it was revealed that it had been generated using AI technology without proper disclosure. Ellis had uploaded 40,000 words of her own original work into a Copilot Large Language Model, which assisted in drafting her article. The university stated that this use of AI was appropriate and reflected her expertise. Despite this, the Sydney Morning Herald's editor, Jordan Baker, noted that the article did not meet editorial guidelines, as AI usage was not disclosed by either the author or the university. This incident raises significant questions about academic integrity and the ethical use of AI in writing, as similar cases have emerged in media outlets globally, leading to concerns about transparency and authenticity in journalism.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
The incident raises concerns about the integrity of academic work and the role of AI in education.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Reader Poll
What is your opinion on the use of AI in academic writing?
Connecting to poll...
Read the original article
Visit the source for the complete story.



