In response to rising allegations of antisemitism, several US universities, such as the University of Washington and New York University, are establishing centers dedicated to studying antisemitism. Faculty at these institutions report feeling marginalized as new initiatives often prioritize ideological perspectives over established scholarly expertise. For instance, the University of Washington's center, which claims to foster open inquiry, has faced criticism for hosting primarily pro-Israel events and for its leadership structure lacking in Jewish studies expertise. This trend is part of a broader movement across US campuses, where antisemitism is increasingly viewed through a political lens, often leading to tensions within Jewish studies departments. Scholars fear that the focus on antisemitism may overshadow other critical academic discussions, particularly regarding the complex relationship between antisemitism and criticism of Israel. As universities respond to external pressures, including potential lawsuits and donor influence, the integrity of academic discourse is at stake. The establishment of these centers raises important questions about the future of Jewish studies and the nature of scholarly inquiry in a politically charged environment.