The Urgent Need for a Constitutional Right to Housing in Ireland
Lorcan Sirr: Oliver Bond residents are suffering the slow violence of State neglect
Image: The Irish Times
Context
Oliver Bond House is a housing complex in Dublin, Ireland, suffering from severe neglect and poor living conditions. The complex has faced issues such as overcrowding, dampness, and pest infestations, which have led to significant health problems for its residents.
What The Author Says
This piece argues that the absence of a constitutional right to housing in Ireland perpetuates systemic neglect, particularly affecting vulnerable residents like those in Oliver Bond House. The government's failure to prioritize adequate housing conditions reflects a broader disregard for human rights and dignity.
Key Arguments
Facts and Opinions in the article
📗 Facts
- Oliver Bond House was built in 1936 and consists of 16 blocks with flats averaging 48 square meters.
- The European Committee of Social Rights criticized Ireland for failing to ensure adequate housing standards in 2017.
- The Department of Housing announced it would not fund a €20 million redevelopment due to a reduction in the number of flats.
📕 Opinions
- The current state of housing in Ireland reflects a systemic failure to prioritize citizens' rights.
- A constitutional right to housing would fundamentally change how housing policies are developed and implemented.
- The government's inaction on housing rights demonstrates a lack of accountability and commitment to social justice.
Counterpoints
The government already has legal authority to address housing issues.
Some argue that existing laws are sufficient to tackle the housing crisis without needing constitutional amendments.
A constitutional amendment could complicate housing policy implementation.
Opponents may contend that a constitutional right could lead to bureaucratic hurdles and slow down necessary reforms.
Not all countries with housing rights have solved homelessness.
Critics might point out that even countries with constitutional rights to housing still face significant homelessness and housing shortages.
Bias Assessment
The author emphasizes the need for systemic change while potentially overlooking the complexities of implementing such constitutional amendments.
Why This Matters
The ongoing housing crisis in Ireland, marked by rising homelessness and inadequate living conditions, makes the discussion on housing rights particularly urgent. Recent criticisms from the European Committee of Social Rights highlight the need for immediate action.
🤔 Think About
- •What are the potential drawbacks of enshrining housing rights in the constitution?
- •How might existing legal frameworks be improved without constitutional changes?
- •What lessons can Ireland learn from other countries with successful housing policies?
- •How do political ideologies influence housing policy decisions in Ireland?
Opens original article on The Irish Times
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Reader Poll
Should Ireland enshrine a right to housing in its constitution?
Connecting to poll...
