B.C. Tribunal Orders Woman to Refund Engagement Ring Cost After Breakup
B.C. woman ordered to refund cost of engagement ring after relationship ends
Ctv News
Image: Ctv News
A tribunal in British Columbia has mandated a woman to refund her former fiancé over $5,000 for an engagement ring after ruling that she likely kept it following their relationship's end. The decision highlights B.C. law, which typically requires the return of engagement rings if the engagement is broken before marriage.
- 01The engagement ring was valued at $4,859.68.
- 02The tribunal ordered the respondent to reimburse $5,055.80, including tribunal fees and expenses.
- 03The respondent claimed the ring was a gift and could not locate it after the breakup.
- 04Text messages revealed the respondent's contradictory statements regarding the ring's whereabouts.
- 05B.C. law stipulates that engagement rings should be returned to the purchaser if the engagement ends before marriage.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
A British Columbia tribunal has ruled that a woman must reimburse her former fiancé $5,055.80 for an engagement ring after determining she likely retained it following their breakup. The dispute arose from a March 2020 proposal where the applicant gifted a ring valued at $4,859.68. After their relationship ended in August 2022, the applicant repeatedly requested the ring's return, but the respondent claimed she could not find it, asserting it was a gift. The tribunal, led by vice-chair Kandis McCall, examined text messages exchanged post-breakup, which showed the respondent's inconsistent claims about the ring's location. The tribunal concluded that under B.C. law, the ring must be returned to the original purchaser if the engagement is terminated before marriage. Since the respondent insisted she did not have the ring, the tribunal ordered her to reimburse the full purchase price instead, along with additional fees related to the dispute.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
This ruling clarifies the legal obligations regarding engagement rings in British Columbia, potentially influencing future disputes over similar issues.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Reader Poll
Should engagement rings be considered gifts or property to be returned?
Connecting to poll...
Read the original article
Visit the source for the complete story.



